黙あらじと言のなぐさに言ふことを
聞き知れらくは悪しくはありけり
聞き知れらくは悪しくはありけり
- Roma-ji
-
Moda araji to koto no nagusa ni iu koto o kikishireraku wa ashiku wa arikeri
- English Translation
-
"I must not stay mute"—
so, for comfort of mere words,
you say what you say;
to hear it and know it so
has been a bitter thing
- Meaning
- Thinking you should not stay silent, you say things only to comfort me with words—and to hear them, knowing them for what they are, has been hard indeed.
- Commentary
-
Book Seven Miscellaneous Poems 1258
Headnote continued from the preceding poem: "Occasional Poems"
The speaker hears the words the other offers only as empty comfort, because staying silent would not do, and finds it painful to hear them knowing what they are. The loneliness of one who sees through kind but hollow words is stated frankly.
It is one of the occasional poems and is read as lamenting a lover's heartless words. It comes from the Old Poetry Collection. The poet is unknown.
The first line, "I must not stay mute," has an extra syllable.
The second line, "for comfort of mere words," means solace in words alone.
The third line, "you say what you say," refers to what the other person says.
In the fourth line, "shireraku" is a nominalized form of "shireri": "the fact of knowing."
In the final line, "keri" expresses a realization: "it has been a bitter thing."
- Source
- Manyoshu
- Prev Poem
-
Michinobe no kusafukayuri no hanaemi ni emishi ga kara ni tsuma to iu beshi ya
- Next Poem
-
Saekiyama unohana mochishi kanashiki ga te o shi toriteba hana wa chiru tomo